The fashion industry is a fast paced, trendy, constantly changing, and sometimes confusing concept. Trends come and go without any notice and most of us feel like hamster spinning a stylish wheel.
One of the biggest problems the fashion industry creates is in the world of intellectual property. The US, and in most other countries, there is very little protection for designers. This trend started a long time ago when the courts decided that fashion designs are too utilitarian to let a handful of people own.
This makes sense when you think about it. Can you imagine if someone owned a patent for skinny jeans? What would baristas and philosophy majors wear? Every time Levis wanted to sell a pair of 501s, they would have to get it licensed through the owner of the patent.
You can’t patent or copyright the physical product, but you can get a trademark for a logo. This is why lots of high-end designers plaster their logo on purses and shoes. If someone tries to make a knock off, they have to alter the logo to avoid trademark infringement.
At first glance it seems like designers are getting the short end of the stick, but some fashion experts argue it’s good for the industry. By not offering protection it propels designers to constantly be innovative.
After getting frustrated by the lack of IP laws, Stuart Weitzman, a well-known shoe designer, started designing shoes that engineered in such a way that only his blend of materials would work. If counterfeiters tried to make the shoe with cheaper materials the shoe would break.
Other fashionistas argue that IP laws should do more for the designers. The American Apparel and Footwear Association has been a huge proponent of IP protection.
The courts have been, and will most likely continue to be, hesitant to award IP rights to fashion designers. One reason for this is the novelty standard is hard to set.
Novelty standard is a complex issue that probably deserves at least 3 blogs, but we’ll briefly touch on it. This term refers to the originality of an item. If the item is patentable, it will be truly one of kind, and there will no other patents on record like this item.
In fashion the novelty standard is hard to meet because a designer would have to prove that their design has never been made before and therefore, they deserve to own rights.
The fashion industry’s current IP situation creates a very interesting debate about how ownership rights and the progression of creativity work together. This debate will continue to go on, and we’re happy to be part of the conversation.
"Our company has worked with a number of patent attorneys and were so pleased when we began working with Parsons & Goltry nearly a decade ago. Mike Goltry's knowledge and attention to detail has enabled us to have numerous products patented and trademarks registered. We highly recommend this Law Firm."
"Michael Goltry is the most professional, honest and effective patent attorney whom I ever met in my 40 year professional engineering career. I started to work with him over 20 years ago and plan to work indefinitely."
"Mr. Goltry took a provisional patent that we'd filed ourselves, and quickly and professionally turned our innovation into U.S. and foreign applications. His [patent claims] were a thing of beauty, and I was amazed by how deftly he countered the inevitable office actions. His language held up, and the U.S. Patent just issued. He was easy and efficient to work with, and his fees were remarkably reasonable. We're not planning to go anywhere else, ever."
"I applied for a patent through Parsons & Goltry. After being on the docket for 2 years at the USPTO, I received notification that my patent request had been denied. Michael Goltry contacted me immediately to review my options. After I informed him of my decision to move forward, he filed a response to the USPTO. In his response he got the examiner to fully understand the claims in the patent application and the "denied" decision was reversed. I was able to secure and receive a "patent granted" decision. Thank you, Michael Goltry."
10643 North Frank Lloyd
Wright Blvd. Suite 201
Scottsdale, AZ 85259
Phone: (480) 991-3435
Open 9-5pm Monday - Friday
Phoenix’s premiere patent attorneys serving clients throughout the US and internationally for over 20 years.
Our office is located in Scottsdale, Arizona, but we service clients throughout the United States and Internationally.